🚗 Best Mechanics in Toronto, ON (Top 8 Reviewed & Recommended)

Need a trustworthy shop in Toronto for repairs, inspections, or maintenance before refinancing, selling, or just keeping your car solid? These mechanics are frequently recommended by locals, have strong reputations, and specialize in various services.

1. Central Import

⭐ Rating: ~4.8 / 5 (≈ 371 reviews)
📍 Location: 472 King Street E, Toronto, ON M5A 1L7
💬 What They’re Known For: Specialists in European imports (Mercedes, BMW, Audi, etc.), advanced diagnostics, personalized service, digital inspections.
🧠 Why They Stand Out:

• Customers often mention honesty, clear communication, and not being pushed into unnecessary repairs.
• They’ve been around a long time — strong experience with European brands since the late 1970s.

2. Peter’s Garage For Imports

⭐ Rating: ~4.9 / 5 (≈ 83-110 reviews)
📍 Location: 5 Robert St, Toronto, ON M5S 2K2
💬 What They’re Known For: European / imported vehicles, excellent diagnostics, quality work, strong customer service, expertise with VW/Audi.
🧠 Why They Stand Out:

• Reviewers praise their knowledge (“mechanical genius”) and honesty.
• They take time to explain what needs to be done versus what can wait.
• Sometimes considered a bit more expensive than generic shops—but many feel the dealership-level import care and attention is worth it.

3. Starling Automotive Inc

⭐ Rating: ~4.7 / 5 (≈ 113 reviews)
📍 Location: 15 Carlyle St, Toronto, ON M5T 2R3
💬 What They’re Known For: Honest advice, competitive pricing, great customer service, doing complicated and simple repairs alike (foreign/domestic).
🧠 Why They Stand Out:

• People often say that Starling feels “rare” for how upfront and transparent they are.
• Long-standing local reputation; owner deeply involved.

4. Auto Experts – Car Repair Shop (The Junction)

⭐ Rating: Good reputation, frequent positive reviews (details vary)
📍 Location: 2692 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1Y2
💬 What They’re Known For: Family-owned, clean/organized shop, friendly staff, transparency in pricing, reliability.
🧠 Why They Stand Out:

• Many customers appreciate they don’t try to upsell and that they explain work clearly.
• It’s good for people in the west Toronto / Junction area looking for a solid local shop.

5. XIUCHE (European Car Repair Experts, Markham / GTA)

⭐ Rating / Quals: Red Seal / Ontario-certified mechanics; licensed & insured shop.
📍 Location: Markham, Ontario (serving Toronto / GTA)
💬 What They’re Known For: Specialized experience with European luxury brands (Mercedes-Benz, BMW, Audi, Porsche). Strong diagnostic capabilities, uses proper tools, factory diagnostic platforms.
🧠 Why They Stand Out: If you want specialist skills for imports, European luxury car work, this shop brings more of the dealership-depth tools. Good if your car has tricky or sensitive systems.

6. Master Mechanic High Park

⭐ Rating / Feedback: Very positive reviews for customer service, fair pricing, and integrity.
📍 Location: High Park area, Toronto
💬 What They’re Known For: Great for general repair and maintenance. People note they have been loyal for years, trust this shop with serious mechanical issues.
🧠 Why They Stand Out: The community feels looked after; “no games”, “they keep my car safe” is common phrasing. Good place for folks wanting fairness and honesty.

7. Greenwood Auto Repair

⭐ Rating: ~4.6-4.7 / 5 for many reviewers in directory listings
📍 Location: 264 Greenwood Ave, Toronto, ON M4L 2R5
💬 What They’re Known For: Solid service, good in more residential neighborhoods. Kind of “neighbourhood garage” feel.
🧠 Why They Stand Out: If you’re close by, this kind of shop can offer better price / personalized attention compared to large chains. Good for routine maintenance.

8. Main Auto Repair

⭐ Rating: ~4.7 / 5 (≈ 73 votes)
📍 Location: 222 Main Street, Toronto, ON M4E 2W1
💬 What They’re Known For: Reliable basic repairs and service at reasonable rates, fair practices.
🧠 Why They Stand Out: Good option if you want something dependable and more “straightforward” without going to a specialty shop.

⚠️ Honourable Mentions & Reader-Tips (from forums & community feedback)

• Reddit threads often mention iGarage in Markham as being honest and good for import work.
• For people in Etobicoke, shops like Nelson’s Certified Auto Repair are praised for professionalism and good value.
• Starling Automotive is frequently given as a recommendation when someone wants work done without feeling pressured or upsold.

🛠 What to Ask / How to Pick Before You Go

• Are the mechanics certified/licensed in Ontario (e.g. 310S / Red Seal)?
• Do they give written estimates (labour + parts)?
• Can they explain which repairs are urgent vs which ones can wait?
• Do they use OEM-quality parts (especially for imports)?
• What kind of warranty or guarantee do they offer on labour and parts?
• How busy are they / what wait times are like? Don’t assume quickest is best.
• Read recent reviews (last 6-12 months) to see current service level.